Planning Application

Case number W/13/02463/PN

Change of use of existing building to import stone for manufacture. Proposal also seeks to extend the front of the building by 7 metres.

Location: Fish Hill Quarry, Fish Hill, Broadway, WR12 7LL

Other planning applications at this location View location on map

Application Type: Non-householder planning application

Parish: Broadway

Ward: Broadway & Wickhamford

Application Received: 29 November 2013

Statutory Start Date: 12 December 2013

Consultation Period From: 17 December 2013

Consultation Period End: 29 January 2014

Decision Date: 6 February 2014

Case Officer: Anna Brindle

Status: Decided

Decision: Refused - Planning

This decision is subject to the following conditions:

  1. This application proposes the re-use, retention and substantial extension of a building which was only granted temporary permission due to its essential need in connection with the temporary quarrying activities taking place on the land at that time.

    The permanent retention and extension of this building, along with the retention of hardstanding areas, would prevent the full implementation of the approved quarry restoration scheme agreed within plan "BWY/006" of Planning Permissions 08/000029/CM and 08/000024/CM. As such the approved change of use would introduce a industrial development within an area which, once fully restored, would be of agricultural use.

    The development would therefore fail to conserve the landscape and scenic beauty of the AONB and surrounding natural landscape due to the sizable extension, hardstanding areas and associated delivery/employee vehicles required in connection with the stone manufacturing use proposed. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Local Plan policies ENV1 and ENV2, and paragraph 115 of the NPPF.

  2. The building is sited within a location outside of any defined development boundary as identified by the Wychavon District Local Plan and hence is in an unsustainable location.

    No evidence has been submitted with the application to explain why the business needs to be located within an isolated rural location, neither has any evidence been submitted to demonstrate that alternative sites on industrial parks have been considered for their suitability. This application fails to demonstrate any essential need to be located within a rural area and fails to show benefits of the proposal that outweigh the harm casued.

    As a result, the approval of this application would be considered contrary to Local Plan Policy GD1 which directs most new development to the main built up areas within the District and fails to contribute to the achievement of sustainable development as defined in the National Planning Policy Framework.

View application at Wychavon website View planning documents

Top of page


Mr B Wright
Wrights of Campden
42 Littleworth
Chipping Campden


Mr M Richards
Smiths Gore
York House
Blackbrook Business Park

Other planning applications at this address

Date: 12 May 2008
County Matters: No Objections - County Matter
Continuation of development without compliance of conditions.
More details...

Top of page

Location Map

Note: The map marker shows the approximate centre of the application postcode, if available, or the nearest geocoded location from the address. The actual location may be slightly different.

Top of page